Content Marketing

Google Content Effort: What We Know, What We Don’t, and How to Audit It

DO
Written by
Derrick Okoroh
Founder
Reviewed
6 October 2026
On this page

Google’s leaked Content Warehouse documentation contains an attribute called contentEffort, described as an “LLM-based effort estimation for article pages.”

That discovery is interesting, but it is easy to overstate what it proves.

We know Google documented a system capable of estimating content effort. We also know Google’s Quality Rater Guidelines explicitly ask raters to consider the effort involved in creating satisfying content.

What we do not know is whether contentEffort is currently used as a direct ranking signal, how much weight it receives if it is, or whether improving an estimated content-effort score causes rankings to improve.

That attribute is at the centre of the discussion. SEO consultant Shaun Anderson summarised the leaked description and was careful to add that its weighting — or whether it is used in ranking at all — is unknown: Shaun Anderson on contentEffort (@Hobo_Web).

The useful SEO question is therefore not:

“How do I optimise for the contentEffort score?”

It is:

“What evidence makes a page look like someone actually invested expertise, judgement and resources into making it more useful than the information already available?”

That is something we can work with.

What is Google Content Effort?

Content effort describes the observable work that has gone into making a page useful. It is not simply how many hours somebody spent writing it.

A 5,000-word article assembled from information already ranking on Google may represent hours of work while contributing almost nothing new. A 600-word page containing an original experiment, proprietary dataset or useful calculator could require considerably more expertise and investment.

The distinction is visible contribution. It is the same idea behind non-commodity content: material that is hard to replicate because it carries first-hand experience, data or judgement.

Google’s Quality Rater Guidelines give us an official reference point. Raters are asked to consider the extent to which human effort has gone into creating satisfying content — effort that can appear in the content itself, but also in functionality, research, curation, testing and the systems behind a page.

The leaked documentation adds another piece to the picture through contentEffort.

What the evidence actually tells us

Internal documentation can tell us Google stores or calculates something. It does not tell us where that information is used, how heavily it is weighted, or whether it is in production ranking. Here is what the evidence supports, and at what confidence:

ClaimEvidenceConfidence
Google has documented an attribute named contentEffortLeaked Google documentationHigh
It is described as an LLM-based effort estimation for article pagesLeaked Google documentationHigh
Google’s Quality Rater Guidelines explicitly evaluate effortOfficial Google documentationHigh
Effort includes more than simply writing textOfficial Google documentationHigh
contentEffort is currently a direct ranking factorNot publicly confirmedUnknown
A higher contentEffort value directly produces higher rankingsNot publicly confirmedUnknown
Google uses Gemini specifically to calculate the valueHypothesisUnknown
Treat contentEffort as evidence about the direction of Google’s quality systems — not as a metric you can optimise like a title tag. The documentation shows Google calculates something; it does not confirm where it is used, how heavily it is weighted, or whether it is part of production ranking.

Content effort is not word count

One of the easiest mistakes is interpreting “effort” literally. More words do not automatically mean more effort. Neither do:

  • longer production times;

  • publishing more frequently;

  • manually writing everything;

  • adding more headings;

  • inserting more keywords;

  • adding generic stock imagery;

  • turning a 1,000-word article into a 3,000-word article.

These things can make a page bigger without making it better — they are data without direction. The more useful distinction is between commodity information and contributed information.

Illustration contrasting a tall stack of blank grey pages with a single warmly lit page holding a product photo and green bar shapes.
More pages isn’t more effort. One page carrying original evidence outweighs a stack of commodity copy.

Commodity information already exists across dozens or hundreds of pages. Definitions, generic tips, standard feature lists and summaries of other sources are relatively easy to reproduce. Contributed information exists because you did something:

  • you tested the product;

  • you interviewed the expert;

  • you analysed the dataset;

  • you built the calculator;

  • you photographed the process;

  • you compared the results;

  • you found the exception;

  • you developed a methodology, made a judgement and showed the evidence behind it.

This is close to how Cyrus Shepard frames it: Google’s definition of effort “isn’t what most people think,” and effort ≠ work — what counts is evidence of useful work visible in the finished page. His post: Cyrus Shepard on what effort means (@CyrusShepard).

The BeSERP Replicability Test

Here is a simple test we use when evaluating content:

Could a competent writer reproduce 90% of this page using Google, an LLM and the existing search results — without speaking to us, using our data or accessing our experience?

If the answer is yes, the page probably has a weak information moat. This doesn’t automatically make the page bad — some queries only require straightforward answers. But for competitive informational searches, it exposes an important weakness: the page may be relevant without contributing anything distinctive to the search result.

Run the same test against your competitors. If five ranking pages all explain the same ten points and your planned article explains those same ten points with different wording, you have probably created another version of the existing SERP rather than improved it.

That is where content effort becomes strategically useful. Don’t ask:

“What do the top-ranking pages contain?”

Ask:

“What would make my page useful even if the reader had already visited the top-ranking pages?”

That is a much harder question. It is also where genuinely valuable content tends to start.

7 observable signs of high-effort content

We cannot see Google’s internal contentEffort calculation. We can inspect the things users — and potentially machine-learning systems — can observe on a page. We use seven dimensions when evaluating this.

1. Original contribution

Does the page introduce information that did not simply come from other search results? This could include proprietary data, survey findings, original experiments, customer data, first-hand observations, interviews, original examples or expert conclusions.

Originality does not require conducting a national study every time you publish. Sometimes the contribution is simply an expert explaining what actually happens in a situation that generic documentation does not cover. The important question is whether the page adds information rather than merely rearranging it.

2. First-hand evidence

Claims become more useful when the reader can see where they came from. For example, compare:

Changing title tags can improve CTR.

with:

We changed the title across these 42 URLs, held the page content constant and compared Search Console CTR over the following 28 days. Here is what happened.

The second statement exposes the work behind the conclusion. Screenshots, test results, photographs, examples, dates, datasets and methodology all make experience more visible.

3. Editorial judgement

Curation itself can require effort. A page containing 100 SEO tools is not automatically more useful than one containing five. Someone who has actually used the tools can tell the reader which they would choose, which they would avoid, where each fails, who each is appropriate for, and what trade-offs matter. That judgement transforms information into guidance.

4. Verification

High-effort content does not simply repeat claims because other websites repeat them. Important claims should be traced back to their strongest available source. This is particularly important when discussing Google’s leaked documentation — there is a major difference between the documentation containing an attribute and the attribute being a confirmed ranking factor. Good research preserves that distinction, and checking whether something is actually true requires more work than repeating it.

5. Original media

Screenshots, diagrams, photographs, charts and video can provide evidence that the creator actually performed the work being described. But simply adding images does not increase quality. A stock photograph of someone typing “SEO” into a laptop contributes very little; a labelled diagram showing how contentEffort, the Quality Rater Guidelines and your interpretation relate to one another can genuinely improve understanding. The test is utility, not image count.

6. Functional utility

Sometimes the most valuable part of a page isn’t an article at all — it might be a calculator, template, checker, filter, dataset, interactive comparison, downloadable worksheet or diagnostic workflow. Building something that lets the reader complete a task creates value another publisher cannot reproduce simply by paraphrasing your text.

7. Maintenance

Effort does not end when you press publish. Some subjects decay quickly: Google documentation changes, products change, SERPs change, research gets superseded. A high-quality resource should make its maintenance visible where appropriate — showing when evidence was last checked, replacing obsolete screenshots, updating examples, recording significant methodology changes, and removing claims that can no longer be substantiated. A page that was excellent two years ago can still become low-value if the world it describes has changed — which is the moment to fix content decay rather than let the page quietly slip.

The Content Effort Matrix

Before publishing, evaluate the page across these seven dimensions.

DimensionWeak evidenceStrong evidence
Original contributionSummarises existing articlesAdds proprietary findings, experience or analysis
First-hand evidenceMakes unsupported assertionsShows tests, screenshots, examples or methodology
Editorial judgementLists informationEvaluates and prioritises it
VerificationRepeats secondary claimsTraces important claims to primary evidence
Original mediaDecorative stock imageryCustom diagrams, screenshots, photography or video
Functional utilityReader only consumes informationReader can perform a useful task
MaintenancePublish-and-forgetEvidence and examples are periodically reviewed
This is not Google’s scoring system. It is a practical BeSERP framework for spotting where a page demonstrates useful work and where it merely contains information — because nobody outside Google can calculate the internal contentEffort value from a URL.
Interactive · Grade your page

Content Effort Grader

Rate a page honestly on the seven signals below. Everything runs in your browser — nothing is sent or stored.

Original contribution
Summarises existing articles → Adds proprietary findings, experience or analysis
First-hand evidence
Makes unsupported assertions → Shows tests, screenshots, examples or methodology
Editorial judgement
Lists information → Evaluates and prioritises it
Verification
Repeats secondary claims → Traces important claims to primary evidence
Original media
Decorative stock imagery → Custom diagrams, screenshots, photography or video
Functional utility
Reader only consumes information → Reader can perform a useful task
Maintenance
Publish-and-forget → Evidence and examples are periodically reviewed
Rate all seven signals to see your grade · 0/7 done

A self-assessment framework based on this article — not Google’s internal contentEffort score.

Low-effort vs high-effort content

Consider two pages targeting “best CRM software for small businesses.”

Page A

The writer searches the keyword, reads the ranking articles and asks an LLM to compile the most frequently recommended products. The final article contains:

  • 3,500 words;

  • 15 products;

  • feature descriptions;

  • pricing copied from vendor sites;

  • stock/product imagery;

  • a generic FAQ.

The article may be accurate. It may also be well optimised. But almost everything on it can be recreated without ever using the products.

Page B

The publisher selects eight CRMs and creates a test account for each. They define five tasks a small business commonly performs, record completion time, document limitations, capture screenshots and interview three small-business users. The resulting page contains only 2,000 words. But it also contains:

Illustration of a person testing software on a laptop at a desk with a timer, a pinned checklist and a notebook comparison grid.
Page B’s edge is first-hand testing: timing real tasks and recording what actually happened.
  • the testing methodology;

  • original screenshots;

  • task completion data;

  • unexpected limitations;

  • recommendations by business type;

  • conclusions based on actual use.

Which page required more meaningful effort? More importantly: which page gives the reader something they couldn’t obtain by asking an LLM to summarise the existing search results? That is the distinction SEOs should care about.

Content effort depends on the page type

There is no universal high-effort template. The work needed to make a useful page depends on its purpose — and on the keyword types and intent behind the query.

Page typeEvidence of meaningful effort
Product reviewActual testing, original photos, methodology, strengths and weaknesses
How-to guideFirst-hand process, screenshots, failure points, troubleshooting
Research articleDataset, methodology, sample size, analysis, limitations
SaaS landing pageProduct demonstrations, use cases, screenshots, proof, clear functionality
Ecommerce categoryUseful filters, product knowledge, comparison assistance, original product information
Local pageFirst-hand local knowledge, staff/location evidence, genuinely location-specific information
Statistics pageOriginal dataset or careful primary-source aggregation with methodology
Programmatic pageUnique underlying data or functionality rather than keyword-swapped templates
Calculator / toolAccurate functionality, transparent assumptions, useful outputs and explanation

This is why word count is such a poor proxy for effort. A currency converter may satisfy its purpose with almost no conventional article content — building and maintaining the converter itself is the effort.

Does AI-generated content have low content effort?

Not automatically. The more useful question is: what did automation replace, and what did the publisher contribute?

AI can assist with structuring information, summarising research, editing, analysing datasets, generating initial drafts and identifying gaps — and the same holds for AI checkers and paraphrasing tools, which can speed the work without replacing the contribution. None of those automatically make the final page low quality. The problem begins when automation becomes the entire value chain:

search existing information → summarise it → publish it → repeat at scale.

That process can produce grammatically excellent pages while adding almost nothing to the web. A stronger AI SEO workflow looks different:

identify a genuine information need → collect evidence → perform original work → use AI where useful → apply expert judgement → verify claims → publish.

AI reduces the cost of producing words. It does not remove the need to produce information worth reading — and this mirrors Google’s own guidance on using generative AI content, which judges the output, not the tool. As competent prose becomes cheaper, original information becomes more valuable.

Lily Ray makes the structural version of this argument: the real issue is page quality, not whether a publisher used an LLM. As she puts it, “the marginal cost of publishing is one of the only things standing between a healthy index and total chaos.” Her post: Lily Ray on the marginal cost of publishing (@lilyraynyc).

A practical content-effort audit

You can audit an existing page without pretending to know Google’s internal score — and it pairs well with a free technical SEO audit for the issues content alone can’t fix. Start with one question:

Top-down illustration of hands highlighting a bar chart on a printed page beside a checklist and a magnifying glass.
Audit the page for what exists only because you created it.

1. What exists on this page because we created it?

Highlight every element that would disappear if you removed your experience, your customers, your data, your research, your expertise, your tools and your testing. If very little disappears, the page is probably heavily dependent on commodity information.

2. What is the strongest evidence?

Find the best thing on the page — a dataset, quote, screenshot, calculation, expert recommendation or tool. Now ask: how quickly does the reader encounter it? Unique value buried beneath 800 words of generic introduction is still buried.

3. What claims have we actually verified?

Separate claims into Confirmed, Supported but uncertain, Interpretation and Hypothesis. This is especially useful when covering patents, leaks, algorithms and statements from Google. Confidence should match evidence.

4. What did competitors leave unanswered?

Don’t only run a content-gap analysis based on keywords. Run an evidence-gap analysis. Look for unanswered questions, unsupported claims, missing examples, outdated information, missing datasets, weak explanations, absent counterarguments and tasks readers still cannot complete.

Those gaps often represent better opportunities than adding another H2 because three competitors have it. A structured content brief is where this evidence-gap analysis becomes a plan.

5. Could someone reproduce this tomorrow?

Return to the BeSERP Replicability Test. If a competitor could recreate the page tomorrow with public search results and an LLM, identify what would make that reproduction difficult. That is where the next investment should go.

How to increase content effort without creating filler

Increasing effort does not mean adding more content indiscriminately. It means allocating production resources where they create additional utility. Instead of adding another 1,000 words, you might:

  • interview a subject-matter expert;

  • analyse your own Search Console data;

  • run the product yourself;

  • build a small calculator;

  • create an original diagram;

  • document an experiment;

  • collect customer questions;

  • compare competing approaches;

  • show where conventional advice fails;

  • update obsolete evidence.

One original table based on proprietary data can contribute more than ten additional generic sections. This is why the right question during content planning isn’t “How long should this article be?” It is “What would we need to do to make this the most useful version of this resource?” When the answer is clear, generate a content brief to turn it into a production plan.

Content effort and E-E-A-T

Content effort and E-E-A-T overlap, but they should not be treated as interchangeable. Effort can create evidence of experience and expertise. For example:

  • testing a product demonstrates experience;

  • explaining methodology demonstrates expertise;

  • citing primary evidence improves trust;

  • maintaining a long-term body of reliable work can contribute to reputation.

But a high-effort page does not automatically establish authority. A completely unknown publisher could spend six months producing excellent research and still lack the reputation, links, recognition and historical signals of an established institution. Likewise, an authoritative domain can publish something shallow.

This is the counterpoint worth keeping in view. As Charles Floate puts it, “rankings are receipts for trust and authority… not effort” — a reminder that effort is necessary but not sufficient. His post: Charles Floate on trust vs effort (@Charles_SEO).

Content quality should therefore be evaluated as a system rather than reduced to one attribute. For the content side of that system, see our complete guide to being Google-searchable.

Can you measure Google’s Content Effort score?

No public tool can tell you Google’s actual contentEffort value. Google has not provided such a tool or documented a public scoring methodology. Any third-party “Content Effort Score” should therefore be understood as an independent assessment framework rather than Google’s score.

That does not make scoring useless. A consistent framework — or a dedicated E-E-A-T content analysis tool — can help editorial teams identify weaknesses, compare pages and prioritise improvements. The important thing is to label the measurement correctly.

At BeSERP, we prefer evaluating the visible evidence of effort rather than claiming to reverse-engineer a number we cannot observe.

The 60-second BeSERP Content Effort Audit

Before publishing, ask:

  1. Contribution: what does this page add that wasn’t already available?

  2. Evidence: can the reader see proof of the work behind our conclusions?

  3. Experience: what could we only know by actually doing the thing we’re discussing?

  4. Judgement: have we made useful decisions for the reader rather than simply listing information?

  5. Utility: can the reader accomplish something here that competing pages don’t enable?

  6. Replicability: could someone reproduce most of this using an LLM and the current SERP?

  7. Verification: can we trace important factual claims back to reliable evidence?

  8. Maintenance: do we have a reason and a process to keep the resource accurate?

You don’t need to tick every box for every URL. You need enough evidence of meaningful work to satisfy the purpose of the page better than a commodity version of the same information.

How we researched and checked this article

In keeping with the standard this article argues for: the official claims here are drawn from Google’s live documentation on helpful, people-first content, using generative AI content, and the role of quality raters. The contentEffort attribute is presented as leaked documentation, not confirmed ranking behaviour, and practitioner views are attributed to the named individuals with links to the original posts. We did not claim that any specific documentation change happened on a specific date, because that requires comparing dated versions, which we have not done here.

Content effort FAQs

Is contentEffort a confirmed Google ranking factor?

No. contentEffort is an attribute name found in the 2024 Content Warehouse leak, described there as an LLM-based effort estimation for article pages. Google has not confirmed whether it is used in ranking, how heavily, or whether it is still in use. Its existence is not proof that Google ranks pages by an effort score.

Can I measure my Google content effort score?

No public tool can reveal Google’s internal value, and Google has not documented a public scoring method. Any “Content Effort Score” is an independent assessment framework, useful for comparing and improving pages, but it is not Google’s number.

Does AI-generated content always have low content effort?

No. Google judges the output, not the tool. AI-assisted content is fine when a person adds original input, applies expert judgement and verifies claims. The low-effort pattern is using automation as the entire value chain — summarising existing results and publishing at scale with nothing added.

Does more content effort guarantee higher rankings?

No. Effort is a quality Google’s documentation values, but trust and authority still influence whether a page ranks. A high-effort page on a site Google does not yet trust can be outranked by an established source. Effort is necessary for durable content, not a standalone ranking guarantee.

The takeaway

The discovery of Google’s contentEffort attribute is significant because it gives us another window into how Google thinks about page quality. It does not give us a new optimisation score. That distinction matters.

The safest conclusion from the available evidence is much simpler:

Make the work visible.

Don’t manufacture length to demonstrate effort. Don’t assume manually written content is inherently superior to AI-assisted content. Don’t confuse optimisation with contribution. Instead, invest in the things that are difficult to reproduce cheaply: experience, research, data, expert judgement, original media, useful functionality and rigorous verification.

And before publishing, ask one final question:

If every existing article on this subject disappeared tomorrow, what information on our page would still exist because we discovered, tested, built or concluded it ourselves?

The stronger your answer, the stronger your information moat.

D

Derrick Okoroh

Founder

Derrick Okoroh is the founder of BESERP and an SEO practitioner with hands-on experience in content audits, keyword strategy and execution workflows for SaaS and service businesses. He writes about search, content quality and AI-assisted SEO execution.